|
Perspective on Working on an International Disaster
By Kathryn Allen
On Saturday, November 7, 1998, I flew into Soto Cano, the U.S. expeditionary
base in central Honduras. The only sleep I had had in the previous
two days was on the floor of the C-17 that brought me from Puerto Rico
and it was a short flight. I am a Lieutenant Commander and arrived
with the first American military engineering unit, the Seabees, in the
aftermath of Hurricane Mitch.
Early the next morning, an Army colonel drove me to the main north-south
highway in the country. A section of road that spanned a 200-foot
gorge had disappeared. The ravine had been hastily filled with dirt.
18-wheelers hauling bananas to the port where trying to cross and it was
like watching trucks trying to drive on a big bed of jello. The tractor-trailers
would start bouncing up and down like a sine wave studied in geometry.
About 2/3 of the way across the gorge, the truck would sink because the
dirt had not been compacted. An enterprising businessman with a bulldozer
would tow them the rest of the way for a small fee.
I didn’t hesitate when I told the colonel the problem required an engineering
firm, a lot of money, a fair amount of time for the creation of plans and
drawings, and was well beyond the capabilities of the Seabees.
On October 22, 1998, a tropical depression formed in the Atlantic.
Four days later it was a colossal Category 5 storm. Hurricane Mitch
maintained Category 5 status for a continuous 33 hours and for 15 hours
had sustained winds of 180 mph.
When the storm hit Central America, it was so overwhelming that it was
almost a week before news reports got out as to the extent of the destruction.
Water, not wind, wreaked the most havoc. I was deployed to Honduras
for three months, mostly on the northern coast in San Pedro Sula. Here
are some of my perceptions of that havoc.
Corporations weighted in heavily during the recovery effort.
Produce companies, especially Dole and Chiquita, played a critical role
in deciding the reconstruction priority of bridges. (Basically, whatever
low-water crossings were required to open roads leading to the northern
port cities became the main priority of the government also.) I personally
flew with senior managers in company owned helicopters to assess isolated
areas.
Local leadership really matters. In the early phases of the response,
the Mayor of Tegucigalpa (the capitol of the country) died in a helicopter
crash while assessing the damage. The Mayor was a clearly recognized
authority figure who appeared to be coordinating the response. The
power vacuum created by his passing was never completely filled.
Try imagining NYC without Mayor Giuliani after September 11.
The vast majority of the roads were impassable. The loss of a
bridge was the most common reason for a road to be closed.
If a safe road network to distribute relief items doesn’t exist, the quantity
of relief materials being donated becomes inconsequential.
Heavy-duty tractors. There were plenty of trailers that could
haul goods, but very few tractors that could pull the heavy loads over
the hilly terrain. About half of the Seabee tractors could not make
it over the mountains. Lack of adequate tractor-trailers and downed
bridges were the chokepoints of all recovery efforts. The US military
had to contract with local companies for heavy-duty tractors to fulfill
their mission. These were also the same tractors that Dole and Chiquita
were trying to use to get their bananas to the port city of San Pedro Sula
for export. The moral of the story is that the owners of operable
heavy equipment after a disaster make a lot of money.
Sewage disposal is always a huge dilemma in any humanitarian crisis,
but it is greatly exasperated when water supplies become contaminated,
which in turn contaminates the mud that covers everything.
A very bizarre food chain emerged. Animals were eating dead bodies
and then villagers were killing the animals for food.
Managing expectations is very hard. From a purely engineering
viewpoint, for Central America to fully recover from this horrific storm
will require enormous amounts of funding, a sizable amount of time for
proper planning and engineering calculations (especially for the large
spans of bridges lost), and patience. NGO’s do an amazing job helping
victims immediately following a tragedy, but Hurricane Mitch’s harsh legacy
will be measured in decades not weeks.
|